Thursday, March 21, 2013

Sometime it's Better Unseen

Doubt and Molly Sweeney  are both texts that revolve around characters that see things that nobody else can understand. In Doubt, Fr. Flynne see's Ronald Miller as a sad, helpless boy that needs care and guidance. By befriending him, Sister Aloysius see's a completely different relationship taking place. The movie drives viewers to see the relationship that they want to by not ever disclosing what really went on between Ronald and Fr. Flynne.

The main themes of the movie (doubt, intolerance, gossip, and sight) all seem to connect with each other throughout the film. Sister Aloysius first depends on others to believe her accusations, but ends up taking action herself when nobody else will see what she wants them to see. To everyone else at the school, like Sister James and the other students, Fr. Flynne is nothing more than a caring teacher to Ronald. Mrs. Miller, on the other hand, doesn't want to believe that anything is wrong with the relationship because she just wants Ronald to be happy and stay in school. The movie shows that one persons vision can create a massive impact. I believe that the movie reinforces the idea that people see what they want to see.

This still of Ronald looking down and lost is an example of what Fr. Flynne see's. Sister Aloysius looks at Ronald but doesn't see Ronald. Especially after she hears of his "strange" behaviors from Sister James, she takes it upon herself to save him. She's only looking out for herself because in her eyes, she's doing the right thing by extracting Fr. Flynne. Though in the end even she realizes that she let her own sight get in the way of the schools overall vision: a place where teachers guide and care for its students. However, Sister Aloysius' stance is understandable and even relatable. For example, a child could see or hear their parents fighting just one time and come up with a whole theory about divorce and thoughts of hatred. From that point on, all they can think about when they see their parents together is bitterness and rivalry, even if the parents are genuinely loving each other. All it takes is one instance to make an assumption that can snowball into a web of thoughts.

On the other side of sight is blindness; not being able to see anything at all. Molly, in a way, is a parallel to Sister Aloysius, because she feels superior for being able to see, or in this case not see, things that other people cannot. They both seem to take pride in the theories and visions they've come up with in their minds.

"Oh, I can't tell you the joy swimming gave me. I used to thing that the other people in the pool with me, the sighted people , that in some way their pleasure was actually diminished because they could see, because seeing in some way qualified the sensation; and that if they only knew how full, how total my pleasure was, I used to tell myself that they must, they really must envy me." (pg. 19)

Molly's thoughts here really show that sometimes, seeing isn't the best thing. Everyone's been in a situation where they see something that they wish they hadn't. Seeing leads to emotions, even if one doesn't realize it. By being blind, Molly must really feel something before she can analyze it and come to conclusions about how she "see's" it.



3 comments:

  1. great post! I really liked how you connected Molly Sweeney and Doubt. I agree that characters in both works see things they do not understand and because of that they come to conclusions that may not necessarily be true.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Some nice comments about the nature of vision and knowledge, Harry. You also drew some nice parallels between the 2 texts.

    Here's a suggestion: analyze the still image in more detail (ditto on the passage from "M. Sweeney"), and it's "Donald," nor "RONald."

    ReplyDelete
  3. Awesome job, I really liked the comparison of blindness between the two texts. Maybe next time you could incorporate a picture of sister aloyius.

    ReplyDelete